Thu, 09/02/10, 07:03:05 PM

Other recent articles:

Email Newsletter - Get It Now!



 

Published October 25, 2008

How to exercise with bad knees

I can't tell you how many times I've worked with a client who has bad knees.  By now, I hope you've heard me say it enough that exercises like squats and lunges are some of the best types of exercises to do to burn off fat.  But what happens when your knees won't allow it?  Are there any ways to get around bad knees, but still be able to work on the lower body?  The answer is yes.

Before we get into lower body exercises to do, I first want to get into upper body exercises to do.  Your upper body is pain free, so you need to use that to your advantage.  When I have clients with bad knees, I throw in lower body exercises from time to time, but since their upper body is OK, that's what we stick with most of the time.  The important thing is to create circuit-type workouts that keep your Knee X-Ray upper body challenged during the entire workout.  I might have a client do a row exercise, straight into a chest exercise, and back to a row.  Or, if I'm in a gym, I may have a client do an upper body exercise, and then hop on a stationary bike, an elliptical, or a treadmill ... whichever their knees can handle.  I would have them do a short 30-second or so burst on this machine and come back for another round of the upper body exercise.  Whatever upper body exercises you do, make sure you have a general idea of what your workout is going to be because you want to make sure that you don't have a break in between wondering what to do next.

As far as lower body exercises go, we know that squats and lunges are out, so it's time to improvise.  If you have access to weight machines, there's always the option of hopping on one of those, but I like to stay away from machines for the most part.  Another option is to use a step.  Now I know that steps are painful most of the time, but the steps you want to create barely come off the ground.  Exercise steps, you know, those green or purple steps you can buy at any store with a fitness section, are perfect for these exercises.  There are all kinds of exercises to do with a step.  You can do balance exercises, side step ups, backward step ups, forward steps ups, you can add in shoulder presses, curls, raises, etc. with your step ups.  Like I said, an exercise step is a great option to incorporate into your workout.  Another great mode of exercise is using resistance/exercise tubes.  I love these little things because they're extremely versatile.  You can tie a big knot in it and wedge it under the door, or you can tie it around a pole.  Once you do one of these, you can then tie the other end around your foot and start doing different leg exercises like bringing your knee to your chest, leg extensions, leg curls, leg kickbacks, leg holds with the tube tight, raising your leg out to the side or bringing it across your body.  To incorporate a step into your exercise, you can place a step on top of the tube, and do different exercises while lying down on the tube.  You can do different leg holds, leg raises, Butt Blaster-type exercises (kneeling on the ground and pushing your foot up toward the ceiling), etc.  You need to be careful with these exercises, though, so make sure the tube is actually secure under the step so that it doesn't snap up and hit you.

So my suggestions, if you do have bad knees and want to lose weight, are make sure your calorie intake and eating habits are where they need to be.  Incorporate step exercises and resistance tube exercises into your workouts.  Make sure you maximize your effort with upper body exercises.  Have your workouts planned out.  Keep your intensity level up throughout your workouts.  If you don't have any health issues that would prevent you from doing circuit training, then do circuit training, and make sure you find some method of cardio you can do (i.e. bike, walk, row machine, etc.).  If you can incorporate these different techniques into your workouts, your bad knees shouldn't be what stops you from staying healthy and fit.  As always, though, these are just suggestions.  Make sure you get your doctor's approval before trying any of these exercise, as they may not be appropriate for your level of knee problems.

Dan Falkenberg, BA, ACE-CPT, NASM-PES

Dan Falkenberg is the cofounder of Your Live Trainers.  He can be reached at DanFalkenberg.com.

Don't miss my new fitness book, tentatively scheduled to hit stores soon!  Put your name on the VIP waiting list to be notified when and where it’s available for purchase.

Tags: exercise safety, exercise selection, weight loss

Comments

10 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.

tania shaw
February 23, 2009 11:54pm [ 1 ]

I have rsd in my left knee and cant straighten it i am on crutches. I want to do only upper body work outs

Catherine Holman
June 30, 2009 2:38am [ 2 ]

Is the uliptical machine okay to go on. The stairmaster. I gain 40 lbs because of the pain of my knees.

Catherine

Dan
July 13, 2009 9:48am [ 3 ]

Hi Catherine,

Thanks for the comment. With bad knees, the stairmaster probably would cause you some problems. The elliptical, on the other hand, should be just fine. The important thing with the elliptical is to avoid bouncing. Keep you feet flat on it and move the pedals back and forth. Try not to get in a motion where you are bouncing up and down on your toes...that may hurt your knees. Hope that helps.

Dan DanFalkenberg.com

Barb
July 28, 2009 10:10am [ 4 ]

I had broken bone in my foot that has caused me pain and bad kneees, I cant put weight on the left knee or the right foot for too long, what can I do

Barb
July 28, 2009 10:10am [ 5 ]

I had broken bone in my foot that has caused me pain and bad kneees, I cant put weight on the left knee or the right foot for too long, what can I do

Dan
July 31, 2009 2:45pm [ 6 ]

That's a tough one Barb. My thoughts are to listen to your body. There's not really anything specific I can say other than do what you can, and when you feel the pain, it's probably time to stop. I'm sure your doctor would have some ideas since he/she knows the extent of your injury.

gwen
August 6, 2009 7:56pm [ 7 ]

how do you do abdominals or work your core when you can't kneel

Janelle
August 13, 2009 11:50am [ 8 ]

I disagree that using a step is a good exercise for bad knees. In analyzing the source of my bad knees, I believe that mine originated from doing step aerobics religiously. While it was a low step, the continuous weight on the knees really did a number on them. Also, anything besides a total flat walking surface causes pain. Thanks anyway.

Brandi
August 2, 2010 10:10pm [ 9 ]

Hi Dan, is your new book coming out going to show the exercises that you mention above for bad knees? I had two surgeries on my right knee a couple of years ago and unfortunately it did not heal as I hoped it would so I would really love to see these exercises! Please let me know. Thanks.

Dan
August 3, 2010 1:52pm [ 10 ]

Hi Brandi,

Thanks for the question. You know, I wasn't planning on showing the exercises, but I may have to reconsider it now. Is there anything else you would like to see in the book? The goal of the book is to equipment readers with the knowledge of how to formulate their own programs, so if there is something you think would help, I'm all ears. Thanks Brandi.

Dan

Add a Comment

Please be civil.

( )

( Use Markdown for formatting (this is optional))